Every new hire starts with energy and hope. But the first 90 days are make-or-break. This short window often decides if an employee feels confident, committed or lost.
✨
Quick Read
Summary generated by AI, reviewed for accuracy.
The first 90 days are the most important for any new hire. It’s the window where motivation is high but so is the risk of misalignment. A 90 Days Performance Review helps employees feel heard, set clear expectations, and stay on track. According to SHRM, employees who receive structured feedback during this phase are 3.6x more engaged at work.
For HR and managers, this review is more than just a meeting, it’s a retention tool. It reduces costly turnover, improves team morale, and gives everyone a shared direction. With the right questions and structure, it sets the tone for long-term success. Want to make it easier?
According to Gallup, only 12% of employees strongly agree their organization does a great job onboarding. That gap often leads to early turnover, confusion, and missed potential. That’s why a 90 Day Performance Review is not just another HR task, it is a smart strategy to build trust, fix misalignment early, and keep great talent from slipping away.
In fact, organizations with structured 90-day reviews see up to 30% higher retention during the first year of employment. These reviews give new employees a clear space to reflect, ask questions, and feel supported. It’s not about checking a box it is about setting people up for long-term success, right from the start.
What Is a 90 Days Performance Review?
A 90-day performance review is a planned meeting between a manager and a new employee, usually held about three months after the employee joins. It’s a chance for both to talk about what’s going well, what’s been challenging, and what goals should come next.
This is not just a quick check-in. It’s a focused conversation that sets clear expectations, offers helpful feedback, and connects the employee’s role to the company’s bigger goals. According to SHRM, employees who get regular feedback are 3.6 times more likely to feel engaged at work and that starts with reviews like this.
A strong 90-day review builds trust. When employees feel seen and supported early on, they become more confident in their role. It also gives HR and managers a chance to fix issues early before they turn into bigger problems. That’s why this review isn’t just helpful. It’s essential.
Why It Matters for HR
Startups and fast-growing companies can not afford to ignore early warning signs. When goals aren’t clear or feedback is missing, new employees start to drift. And when they disengage, they don’t just leave quietly they take time, energy, and money with them.
According to the Center for American Progress, losing an employee can cost up to 213% of their salary when you factor in lost productivity, hiring, and training a replacement. That’s why a strong Performance Review is not just helpful, it is critical. It creates space for honest feedback, course correction, and clear expectations, all before issues grow out of control.
Even one missed conversation can lead to a missed opportunity. But when HR steps in early with the right process, it sends a powerful message: “We see you. We support you. And we want you to succeed here.”
How 90 Days Performance Review Supports HR Goals
- Aligns Expectations Early
The first 90 days are critical for setting the tone. A structured review ensures both the manager and employee clearly understand what success looks like. It removes guesswork and creates a shared understanding of goals, timelines, and responsibilities. - Encourages Two-Way Feedback
This is not just about the manager talking it’s a two-way street. New employees get to share what’s working and where they need more support. This feedback loop builds trust and helps leaders improve the onboarding experience. - Improves Manager Accountability
Managers are responsible for setting their team members up for success. When they lead 90-day review, they stay more engaged in the onboarding process. It also gives HR insights into how well managers are coaching and supporting new hires. - Creates a Culture of Openness
Starting with honest conversations shows employees that feedback is normal and welcomed. This reduces fear, increases transparency, and sets the foundation for ongoing communication across the organization. - Helps HR Track Onboarding Success
HR can use 90-day reviews to spot patterns in how new hires adjust. If multiple employees struggle with the same issue, it may point to a hiring, training, or team-wide problem that needs fixing. - Reduces Turnover
When employees know where they stand and feel supported, they are more likely to stay. According to Gallup, 70% of employees who experience structured onboarding stay with the company for three years or more.
- Boosts Confidence and Clarity
After a review, employees leave with direction. They know what they’re doing right and what to focus on next. This confidence fuels productivity and helps them settle into their role faster.
- Sets the Tone for Long-Term Growth
When the first 90 days include goal-setting and personal development conversations, it tells the employee that growth matters here. That early message makes a big impact on future engagement.
- Supports Performance Management Later
The 90-day review creates a starting point. It gives HR and managers a reference to measure progress in later reviews, making performance tracking more accurate and fair.
- Improves Company Reputation
A thoughtful onboarding process with structured reviews shows that your company values its people. That boosts internal morale and makes a great impression on future candidates, too.
What to Include in a 90 Day Performance Review
A well-executed 90 days performance review is more than a routine task it’s a chance to set the foundation for long-term success. Below are 10 key areas every HR manager or team lead should cover to make the review meaningful, strategic, and actionable.
Goal Progress
Review the goals that were set during onboarding or the initial weeks. Discuss what has been achieved, what’s still in progress, and what may need to shift. This gives clarity on performance and shows how well the employee has adapted to the role’s expectations.
Role Clarity
Check if the employee fully understands their job responsibilities. Are there any areas of confusion? A review is the perfect time to clarify expectations and correct any misunderstandings before they become performance issues.
Cultural Fit
Evaluate how well the employee is adjusting to the company’s culture. Are they engaging with team members? Do they align with the organization’s values and communication style? Cultural alignment often predicts long-term success.
Skills and Strengths
Highlight the employee’s core strengths observed during the first 90 days. Have they demonstrated leadership, problem-solving, or initiative? Recognizing strengths builds confidence and helps plan for future opportunities.
Roadblocks
Ask about any challenges or barriers they’ve encountered. It might be unclear processes, missing tools, or limited access to support. This part of the review allows HR and managers to proactively resolve issues before they impact performance.
Manager Support
Discuss how the manager has supported the employee so far. Have they received enough feedback, check-ins, and guidance? This section gives HR insight into the effectiveness of the team lead and identifies areas for better support.
Development Plan
Talk about next steps. What skills should the employee focus on next? Are there stretch goals, certifications, or mentorship opportunities to explore? A simple development plan builds motivation and shows that the company is investing in growth.
Team Collaboration
Review how the employee is interacting with peers. Are they actively participating in team meetings? Do they collaborate well across departments? Strong communication and teamwork skills are essential for scaling businesses.
Job Satisfaction and Engagement
Get honest feedback on how the employee feels about the role so far. Do they enjoy the work? Do they feel included and valued? Early signs of disengagement can be addressed quickly if surfaced during this review.
Future Goals and Career Interests
Take time to understand their long-term interests. Do they want to grow into a leadership role? Are they interested in learning a new tool or skill? Aligning personal goals with company objectives increases loyalty and retention.
Benefits of 90 Days Performance Review
A well-structured 90 Days Performance Review is not just a formal HR step it is a powerful retention, engagement, and growth tool. It offers value for the new hire, their manager, HR, and the business overall.
- Sets the Foundation for Long-Term Success
This review sets the tone for what performance and growth will look like in the company. It helps employees understand where they stand, what’s expected, and what good performance looks like. When employees get clarity early, they are more likely to stay on track and contribute with confidence.
- Builds Strong Manager-Employee Relationships
The review encourages an open, structured dialogue between manager and employee. These early conversations foster trust, remove ambiguity, and create space for authentic coaching. It’s easier to fix problems or misunderstandings in the beginning than after 6 months.
- Encourages Early Course Correction
Small issues left unaddressed can grow into bigger ones. This review helps managers identify gaps in performance, communication, or expectations before they impact the wider team. It’s easier to pivot or offer support within 90 days than after damage has been done.
- Supports Continuous Improvement
The 90-day review isn’t only about the employee, it gives HR and leadership real feedback on the onboarding process, role clarity, and manager support. Repeated patterns in feedback can help improve systems, training, or hiring strategies.
- Improves Retention and Reduces Turnover Costs
According to the Center for American Progress, replacing an employee can cost up to 213% of their salary. A 90-day review gives new hires the feedback and support they need to stay, grow, and feel invested reducing the risk of early attrition.
- Drives Goal Alignment
Often, new hires work hard but may not know whether their work aligns with team or company objectives. This review connects individual contributions to the bigger picture. It shows how their role adds value, helping them stay motivated and purpose-driven.
- Gives Employees a Voice
The 90-day review is not just top-down it’s a chance for the new hire to speak openly about their experience. They can share challenges, request clarity, and give feedback on what’s working. When employees feel heard, engagement increases.
- Enhances Team Collaboration
This is the perfect checkpoint to ask: “Is this person blending well with the team?”
Strong collaboration early on prevents friction, builds camaraderie, and fosters a culture of open communication. It also helps managers spot social blockers or onboarding gaps that may affect team dynamics.
- Makes Future Reviews More Effective
The first 90 days become a benchmark. With clear goals, feedback, and documentation in place, it’s easier to track growth during the 6-month and annual reviews. You’ll know what the employee started with and how far they have come.
- Strengthens Employer Brand and Culture
When new hires experience structure, support, and transparency early on, they are more likely to speak positively about your company. A clear 90-day review process shows that you invest in people and care about their success which improves word-of-mouth and internal culture.
Best Practices for HR Teams
When done well, a 90 Day Performance Review builds alignment, trust, and momentum. But it only works if HR leads the process with clarity, consistency, and empathy. Here are key best practices to ensure your reviews create impact, not paperwork.
1. Start with a 30-60-90 Day Framework
Break the employee’s journey into three clear phases.
- First 30 days focus on learning the role, tools, and team culture.
- Next 30 involve applying skills, starting to contribute, and clarifying expectations.
- Final 30 are about delivering results and planning forward.
This phased structure gives new hires a sense of direction and helps managers track progress meaningfully.
2. Use a Consistent Review Template
Don’t reinvent the wheel for every role. Create a standardized 90-day review template that works across teams, then customize for specific job functions.
Consistency promotes fairness and ensures no important topic is missed. It also makes it easier to gather HR data at scale.
3. Make It Conversational
This is not a test. The best reviews feel like a dialogue, not an interrogation.
Encourage open discussion by creating a safe space. Let the employee speak first, reflect honestly, and share what they’ve learned or struggled with.
When employees feel heard, they’re 4.6x more likely to perform at their best (Salesforce Research).
4. Keep It Balanced
Don’t just focus on gaps or problems. Highlight strengths and wins, too.
Balance is key: if the review is all praise, it lacks direction. If it’s all critique, it kills motivation. Use the “Start-Stop-Continue” model to guide feedback and maintain a positive tone.
5. Document Everything
Verbal reviews fade. Documentation builds accountability.
Use your HR software or OKR tools to capture key points, goals, feedback, and action plans. This helps with follow-ups, future evaluations, and performance trends.
6. Use Data
Anecdotes are helpful but numbers build trust.
Include actual performance metrics, attendance logs, task completions, or project delivery timelines to back up your review.
It keeps the process objective and avoids bias.
7. Follow Up
Don’t stop at the 90-day mark.
Schedule a quick check-in 30 days after the review to track progress on action items. This follow-through reinforces that the review wasn’t just a box-ticking exercise it was the start of growth.
8. Train Your Managers
Managers aren’t born knowing how to conduct effective reviews.
Offer coaching, scripts, and checklists to help them deliver reviews that are thoughtful, supportive, and clear. When HR trains managers well, the whole company benefits from stronger leadership.
9. Gather Feedback on the Process
Ask employees how the review felt. Was it useful? Did it help them feel more supported?
Use this input to refine your review process. Continuous improvement applies to HR, too.
10. Link Reviews to Career Growth
Make the 90-day review the first step in a longer career path.
Use it to introduce long-term development plans, mentorship opportunities, and growth tracks within the company. This connects early performance to long-term success and keeps your best talent invested.
Sample 90-Day Performance Review Questions
These questions help spark meaningful conversations between managers and new employees. They go beyond task tracking and help evaluate fit, clarity, and engagement.
- What goals did you achieve in your first 90 days?
This helps you understand what the employee completed versus what’s still pending. Ask for examples, outcomes, and how the goals connected to team priorities.
Follow-up: “Which goal are you most proud of, and why?” - What challenges did you face, and how did you overcome them?
hallenges reveal how employees handle pressure, problem-solving, and unexpected changes. Listen for resilience, creativity, or where support might have been missing.
Follow-up: “Is there anything we could have done to make this easier?” - What support or resources helped you the most?
This uncovers what’s working well in your onboarding and team environment. It also highlights tools, teammates, or learning methods that made a difference.
Follow-up: “Was there anything you wish you’d received earlier?” - Is your role what you expected it to be?
This question explores alignment between job expectations and reality. Disappointment in this area is a key reason for early attrition.
Follow-up: “What’s been the biggest surprise so far?” - How well do you feel integrated with your team?
Early team bonding builds engagement. This question checks if the new hire feels included, informed, and welcomed.
Follow-up: “Is there anyone you’d like more opportunities to work with?” - What feedback have you received so far?
Understanding how feedback is flowing early on helps you support both the employee and the manager. It can also identify gaps in coaching or recognition.
Follow-up: “Was any feedback especially helpful or unclear?” - What would you change about your onboarding experience?
This is a chance to improve your processes. Ask for honest, constructive feedback about orientation, communication, and ramp-up speed.
Follow-up: “What part of onboarding felt most confusing or rushed?” - What are your top goals for the next 90 days?
Look ahead. This helps the employee stay focused and motivated. It also allows the manager to align individual goals with team priorities.
Follow-up: “What support or training would help you achieve those goals?” - How supported do you feel by your manager or team lead?
Employee-manager relationships are the foundation of engagement. If support is missing, performance and retention are at risk.
Follow-up: “Are there specific ways your manager could support you better?” - What would make your work more meaningful or satisfying?This helps you tap into personal motivation and growth potential. Understanding what drives the employee can help you tailor development paths.
Follow-up: “Is there a type of project or task you’re eager to try?”
HR Personas Who Benefit the Most from 90-Day Performance Reviews
A well-run 90 Days Performance Review isn’t just helpful for the new hire it becomes a strategic tool for multiple roles across the organization. Here’s how different HR and leadership personas benefit from this process:
HR Managers
HR professionals are responsible for ensuring structure, compliance, and people performance. With a consistent 90-day review process in place, they can:
- Track onboarding effectiveness across departments
- Identify patterns in performance issues early
- Provide leadership with actionable insights from real employee data
- Strengthen employer brand by demonstrating a commitment to employee success
HR Managers also benefit from having review templates, feedback records, and follow-ups documented clearly, which helps streamline audits, internal communication, and retention strategies.
People Leaders / Team Managers
People leaders are on the front lines of employee development. The 90-day review helps them:
- Provide personalized coaching based on real progress
- Address misunderstandings or misalignment before they grow
- Recognize wins and correct course where needed
- Build strong, trust-based relationships with new team members
By using these reviews, team managers become more proactive and effective in guiding performance rather than reacting to problems too late.
Founders and Executives
In startups or fast-scaling companies, founders are deeply invested in early team building. A structured 90-day review helps them:
- Reinforce a culture of accountability and feedback from day one
- Spot early gaps in hiring or role definition
- Retain key talent by showing care and involvement in development
- Stay connected to how each department is onboarding and aligning new talent
Founders often lack time—but these reviews offer a strategic way to keep a pulse on people performance.
Remote and Hybrid Teams
For teams that work virtually, onboarding can feel disconnected and unclear. The 90-day review helps solve that by:
- Creating structured, face-to-face feedback opportunities even virtually
- Clarifying expectations and reducing ambiguity
- Helping managers check for early signs of disengagement or isolation
- Reinforcing company values and communication expectations
In remote setups, structured feedback becomes more essential not less because casual check-ins are rare.
Conclusion
A strong 90 Day Performance Review strategy helps HR teams set the tone for long-term success. It supports employee growth, increases engagement, and builds trust. More than that, it helps your people feel seen, heard, and supported.
Now is the time to move beyond generic onboarding. Use data, structure, and empathy to make every new hire’s first 90 days count.
Book a demo and get 14 days free to see how performance tracking software can simplify reviews and improve retention.
Join Our Creative Community
Frequently Asked Questions
When should the 90-day review happen?
The review should be conducted around the 90th day of employment. This timing gives the employee enough experience to reflect on their role while ensuring feedback is still relevant and timely. Scheduling the review during onboarding helps ensure it is not missed or delayed.
Who leads the 90-day review?
The direct manager typically leads the review because they work closest with the employee. HR provides the structure, tools, and guidance to support the conversation. HR may also join if needed to help track outcomes and ensure consistency.
Should employees prepare for it too?
Yes. Employees are encouraged to reflect on their experiences during the first 90 days. They should consider what went well, what could be improved, and any feedback or questions they’d like to share. Prepared employees get more value from the review and feel more engaged.
What if the review uncovers major problems?
If the review reveals serious concerns such as gaps in performance, cultural misfit, or lack of clarity it should be addressed with care. A follow-up plan can be created with specific goals and support to guide improvement over the next 30 days. Early intervention prevents issues from growing.
Is one review enough?
No. The 90-day review is only the beginning of a larger feedback process. Regular check-ins, one-on-one conversations, and future performance reviews are needed to maintain alignment, offer support, and track growth over time. Ongoing feedback helps employees stay engaged and successful.
_JiluXJRGNl.svg)
